University of Ciego de Ávila Máximo Gómez Báez
|
ISSN: 2309-8333
|
RNPS: 2411
|14|2026|
This is an Open Access article under the license CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/)
Estrategia y Gestión Universitaria EGU
Scientific and technological
research article
How to cite:
Sornoza-Parrales, D. (2026).
University governance type and
bibliometric performance in the SCImago
Institutions Rankings: evidence from
Ecuador 2017-2026.
Estrategia y Gestión
Universitaria
, 14, e9191.
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23671190
Received: 28/06/2026
Accepted: 15/09/2026
Published: 29/10/2026
Corresponding author:
diego.sornoza@unesum.edu.ec
Conflict of interest:
the authors declare
that they have no conflict of interest,
which may have influenced the results
obtained or the proposed interpretations
.
University governance type and
bibliometric performance in the
SCImago Institutions Rankings:
evidence from Ecuador 2017-2026
Tipo de gestión universitaria y
desempeño bibliométrico en el SCImago
Institutions Rankings: evidencia
ecuatoriana 2017-2026
Tipo de gestão universitária e
desempenho bibliométrico no SCImago
Institutions Rankings: evidências do
Equador 2017-2026
Abstract
Introduction: the bibliometric performance of Latin American
universities is rarely examined by differentiating the
institutional funding models that coexist within the same
national higher education system. Objective: to determine
whether the type of institutional governance is associated
with statistically significant differences in the global
positioning of Ecuadorian universities in the SCImago
Institutions Rankings. Method: a non-experimental
longitudinal quantitative design was adopted using open
secondary data. An unbalanced panel of 187 observations was
constructed for 32 institutions classified into three governance
types according to the Higher Education Council of Ecuador
(CES): public, jointly funded private, and self-funded private.
Intergroup analysis was performed using the Kruskal-Wallis
test, while temporal trends were assessed through Spearman
correlations. Results: no significant differences were found
among the three governance types in any SIR dimension
(maximum H = 5.639; p = 0.060). However, all three groups
exhibited a statistically significant relative decline in global
positioning (rho ranging from +0.706 to +0.817; p < 0.001).
Conclusion: the type of funding is not a predictor of relative
bibliometric positioning. The regulatory convergence
generated by the Organic Law of Higher Education and the
CEAACES/CACES evaluation and accreditation system appears
to have equalized research incentives across institutional
types.
Keywords: institutional performance, higher education,
university ranking
Resumen
Introducción: el desempeño bibliométrico de las
universidades latinoamericanas raramente se examina
diferenciando los modelos de financiamiento institucional
coexistentes en un mismo sistema nacional.
Diego Sornoza-Parrales
1
Universidad Estatal del Sur de Manabí
https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9319-9298
diego.sornoza@unesum.edu.ec
Ecuador
Estrategia y Gestión Universitaria
|
ISSN
: 2309-8333
|
RNPS:
2411
| Vol. 14|2026|
| Diego Sornoza-Parrales |
Objetivo:
determinar si el tipo de gestión institucional se asocia con diferencias
estadísticamente significativas en el posicionamiento mundial de las
universidades ecuatorianas en el SCImago Institutions Rankings.
Método:
se
adoptó un diseño cuantitativo longitudinal no experimental con datos secundarios
abiertos, construyendo un panel no balanceado de 187 observaciones para 32
instituciones clasificadas en tres tipos de gestión según el Consejo de Educación
Superior del Ecuador (CES): pública, particular cofinanciado y particular
autofinanciado. El análisis intergrupal empleó la prueba de Kruskal-Wallis y la
tendencia temporal se evaluó mediante correlaciones de Spearman.
Resultados:
no se evidencian diferencias significativas entre los tres tipos de gestión en
ninguna dimensión del SIR (H máximo = 5.639; p = 0.060). Sin embargo, los tres
grupos exhiben un deterioro relativo en el posicionamiento mundial
estadísticamente significativo (rho entre +0.706 y +0.817; p < 0.001).
Conclusión:
el tipo de financiamiento no es predictor del posicionamiento bibliométrico
relativo. La convergencia regulatoria generada por la Ley Orgánica de Educación
Superior y el sistema CEAACES/CACES habría nivelado los incentivos a la
investigación entre tipos institucionales.
Palabras clave:
desempeño institucional, educación superior, ranking
universitario
Resumo
Introdução: o desempenho bibliométrico das universidades latino-americanas
raramente é analisado considerando os diferentes modelos de financiamento
institucional que coexistem em um mesmo sistema nacional de ensino superior.
Objetivo: determinar se o tipo de gestão institucional está associado a diferenças
estatisticamente significativas no posicionamento mundial das universidades
equatorianas no SCImago Institutions Rankings. Método: adotou-se um desenho
quantitativo longitudinal não experimental com dados secundários abertos,
construindo-se um painel não balanceado de 187 observações para 32 instituições
classificadas em três tipos de gestão segundo o Conselho de Educação Superior do
Equador (CES): pública, privada cofinanciada e privada autofinanciada. A análise
intergrupos utilizou o teste de Kruskal-Wallis, enquanto a tendência temporal foi
avaliada por meio de correlações de Spearman. Resultados: não foram observadas
diferenças significativas entre os três tipos de gestão em nenhuma dimensão do
SIR (H máximo = 5,639; p = 0,060). No entanto, os três grupos apresentaram uma
deterioração relativa estatisticamente significativa em seu posicionamento
mundial (rho entre +0,706 e +0,817; p < 0,001). Conclusão: o tipo de
financiamento não é um preditor do posicionamento bibliométrico relativo. A
convergência regulatória gerada pela Lei Orgânica de Educação Superior e pelo
sistema CEAACES/CACES parece ter nivelado os incentivos à pesquisa entre os
diferentes tipos institucionais.
Palavras-chave:
desempenho institucional, ensino superior, ranking
universitário
| Diego Sornoza-Parrales |
e9191
Introduction
Evaluating the scientific performance of higher education institutions (HEIs)
through bibliometric indicators has become central to both strategic university
management and science and higher education policy. Such evaluation helps locate
universities within the global ecosystem of knowledge production, largely by way of
international rankings, among which the SCImago Institutions Rankings (SIR) stands
out for relying strictly on bibliometric data drawn from Scopus (Carta et al., 2021;
Santos, 2022).
Uncritical use of these indicators, however, often overlooks two
methodological caveats. First, rankings are to a large extent measures of
institutional wealth, because scientific output scales superlinearly with university
income (Lepori et al., 2019). Second, as the list of ranked institutions keeps growing,
existing institutions are pushed down the table even when their actual productivity
has not declined.
Ecuador is a particularly interesting case in this respect. Its higher education
system was restructured beginning in 2008, when the Constituent Assembly passed
Mandate 14, followed in 2010 by the Organic Law of Higher Education (LOES), which
established the regulatory bodies SENESCYT (Secretariat of Higher Education,
Science, Technology, and Innovation), CES (Council of Higher Education), and
CEAACES (Council for the Evaluation, Accreditation, and Quality Assurance of Higher
Education), now called CACES (Council for Quality Assurance in Higher Education;
the acronym CACES is used throughout this article) (Sisa et al., 2020; Gutiérrez et
al., 2023).
Under this framework, research indexed in high-impact databases came to
carry a 21% weight in the CACES institutional evaluation model, which exerted
uniform regulatory pressure on all HEIs regardless of their source of funding (Sisa et
al., 2024). In addition, the Prometeo Program, run by SENESCYT between 2010 and
2016, brought high-profile international researchers into Ecuadorian universities
with the explicit aim of strengthening scientific output (Herrera-Franco et al., 2021;
Pérez Anzardo et al., 2022; Rodríguez et al., 2022).
Ecuador's higher education system formally recognizes three types of HEIs by
funding model, as defined in the LOES and categorized by the CES: (a) public
universities, funded with fiscal resources; (b) co-financed private universities, which
combine state contributions with their own tuition income; and (c) self-financed
private universities, which operate exclusively on their own resources, without state
transfers. This regulatory distinction raises an empirical question with direct
implications for university management: whether differences in how universities are
funded translate into systematic, observable differences in institutional bibliometric
performance as measured by the SIR.
Global university rankings are now among the best known and most debated
tools for institutional evaluation in higher education. Since the launch of the
Shanghai Academic Ranking of World Universities (ARWU) in 2003, their number and
reach have multiplied, and a wide range of actors use them: students choosing an
institution, governments setting excellence policies, funding agencies allocating
resources, and university managers drawing up strategic plans (de la Poza et al.,
| Diego Sornoza-Parrales |
e9191
2021; Nassa & Arora, 2021; Santos, 2022).
The SCImago Institutions Rankings differs from other rankings in that it relies
solely on bibliometric indicators from Elsevier's Scopus database. Recent studies
show that publication counts and citations received largely account for the standings
in university rankings (Robinson-García et al., 2019). The composite indicator
weights three dimensions: Research (50%), Innovation (30%), and Societal (20%). The
variable used in this study is Global Rank, which is each institution's position among
all the HEIs listed in a given annual edition.
One methodological feature of the SIR bears directly on any longitudinal
analysis of changes in institutional rank: each annual edition is calculated over a
cumulative five-year moving window that ends two years before the edition year.
Combined with the minimum inclusion threshold, this means that the universe of
ranked institutions expands over time. Carta et al. (2021) document how the SIR
grew from roughly 3,300 entities in 2010 to more than 8,000 from 2020 onward, and
the expansion has continued: the 2026 edition already exceeds 11,000. This growth
pushes Global Rank values systematically upward. The bias is structural and does not
necessarily reflect any real decline in the absolute productivity of the institutions
involved.
Lepori et al. (2019) provide key evidence on this point. Their data on the
scientific output of more than 2,400 universities in the United States and Europe
show that output scales superlinearly with institutional income: a 10% increase in
budget translates into an increase of more than 10% in publications and citations.
This agrees with studies reporting strong correlations between bibliometric
indicators and positions in international rankings (Szluka et al., 2023). Taylor et al.
(2021) extended the finding to the US university system as a whole, describing scaling
regimes that differ by institutional type. Taken together, the two studies suggest
that management type is, in effect, a proxy for the volume of resources available
for research.
International evidence on the relationship between management type and
scientific productivity is mixed. De la Flor-Martínez et al. (2017) analyzed the
scientific output of Spanish universities and concluded that public universities do
better in total production and impact indices, despite the better production figures
posted by private universities. Javed et al. (2020) report that, in a sample of
Pakistani universities, 92% of Scopus publications come from public institutions,
which employ the largest numbers of full-time researchers.
This advantage is not universal, however. Nguyen et al. (2021) found that in
Vietnam management type mattered less than institutional size and geographic
location. Fu et al. (2023) showed that in Indonesia incentive reforms raised output
across all types of institutions, and management type did not explain differences in
growth. In Colombia, Moreno-Gómez et al. (2019) found that although public
universities outperform private ones in teaching efficiency, research efficiency does
not differ significantly between the two.
In the Ecuadorian context, Sisa et al. (2024) found that private universities
led absolute biomedical output in Scopus over a hundred years of production, and
| Diego Sornoza-Parrales |
e9191
they attributed this result to the pressure effect of the CACES model. The finding
contrasts with comparable Latin American systems, where management type
likewise ceases to be decisive once institutional research policies are controlled for
(Millones Gómez et al., 2021). Gutiérrez et al. (2023) confirmed that each CACES
evaluation cycle (2012, 2015, 2019) coincided with a visible jump in output published
in indexed journals, regardless of management type. Herrera-Franco et al. (2021)
found that 85% of Ecuador's historical Scopus-indexed output was produced in the
last decade.
The literature review points to two competing hypotheses for the Ecuadorian
case.
H1: Regulatory convergence under the LOES/CACES framework has leveled
research incentives across management types, so that no significant differences in
bibliometric performance exist when it is measured relatively through the SIR Global
Rank.
H2: Structural differences in resource availability across management types
would produce observable differences in relative standing, probably favoring public
universities because of their greater access to research funding.
No study in the literature systematically compares the three management
types established in Ecuadorian regulation using the SIR Global Rank as a measure of
relative standing in a longitudinal panel of ten editions. This empirical gap defines
the aim of the present article: to determine whether statistically significant
differences exist in the SIR Global Rank across the Overall, Research, Innovation,
and Societal dimensions among public, co-financed private, and self-financed
private universities in Ecuador during 2017-2026, and to analyze the temporal
trajectory of each group's standing.
Methods and materials
The study adopted a non-experimental, longitudinal, comparative
quantitative design. The unit of analysis was the institution-edition: each
observation corresponded to one Ecuadorian university in one annual edition of the
SIR.
The panel covered the 2017 to 2026 editions (total N = 187 observations; 32
distinct institutions; unbalanced panel because of the SIR inclusion threshold).
Because it relied on open secondary data with no primary data collection, the design
is documentary-bibliometric, in line with the growing body of research that uses the
SIR as a data source for analyzing regional university systems (Vargas-Cuentas &
Roman-Gonzalez, 2021; Carta et al., 2021). Figure 1 shows the sample selection
process, from the initial universe of institutions registered with the CES to the final
panel of institution-edition observations.
Figure 1
Sample selection process
| Diego Sornoza-Parrales |
e9191
Source: Author’s own elaboration.
The main source was the SCImago Institutions Rankings, annual editions
2017-2026, Higher Education sector, filtered by country (Ecuador, code ECU). The
CSV files for each combination of year and ranking dimension (Overall, Research,
Innovation, Societal) were downloaded directly from the public SCImago repository
(www.scimagoir.com). All the downloaded files contain the following columns: Rank,
Global Rank, Institution, Country, Sector and, in the 2026 edition only, Best Country
Quartile.
The SIR applies two inclusion criteria that make the panel unbalanced: (a) a
minimum of 100 Scopus documents in the last year of the reference period, and (b)
at least 75% citable documents out of total output. As a result, the 2017 and 2018
editions include only 6 and 8 Ecuadorian universities, respectively, whereas the 2026
edition includes 30. The number rises steadily across editions, reflecting the growth
of Ecuadorian indexed scientific output documented by Herrera-Franco et al. (2021)
and Gutiérrez et al. (2023). The statistical analysis treats this imbalance as a
limitation.
Institutions were classified by management type by cross-referencing the SIR
list with the CES Register of Institutions (www.ces.gob.ec
), which distinguishes three
categories: (1) public, (2) co-financed private, and (3) self-financed private. This
distinction is consistent with the management indicator frameworks used in
comparative studies of university accreditation in Latin America (Gerón-Piñón et al.,
2021). All 32 institutions identified were coded, with no unclassified cases.
The dependent variable was the SIR Global Rank in four independent
dimensions: Overall (weighted composite indicator), Research (11 research
indicators, 50% of the composite index), Innovation (3 technology transfer and
patent indicators, 30%), and Societal (6 web and social impact indicators, 20%).
Global Rank is a discrete ordinal variable; a lower value indicates a better relative
standing within the SIR's worldwide universe. The main independent variable was
CES management type (three nominal categories). The time-trend variable was the
SIR edition year (continuous, range 2017-2026).
| Diego Sornoza-Parrales |
e9191
Because Global Rank does not meet normality assumptions in small,
heterogeneous groups, only nonparametric tests were used. The three groups were
compared with the Kruskal-Wallis test (the nonparametric equivalent of one-way
ANOVA), whose null hypothesis states that Global Rank distributions are identical
across the three management types. Effect size was quantified with epsilon-squared
(epsilon²), using thresholds of epsilon² ≥ 0.06 (moderate effect) and epsilon² ≥ 0.14
(large effect), in line with the nonparametric methods literature. Because no result
reached statistical significance (p < 0.05), Dunn's post hoc test with Bonferroni
correction was not applicable in any case.
For the temporal trend analysis, Spearman correlations were computed
between edition year and Global Rank Overall for each management group, using
institution-edition data rather than annual medians so as to preserve within-group
variance. A positive correlation indicates that Global Rank rises over time (a relative
decline in worldwide standing), whereas a negative one would indicate sustained
improvement. All analyses were run in Python 3.11 with the scipy.stats library on
the consolidated panel dataset of 187 observations.
Results and discussion
The consolidated panel comprises 187 observations from 32 Ecuadorian
universities with at least one appearance in the SIR during 2017-2026. Table 1 shows
the distribution by CES management type. Public universities are the largest group,
both in institutions (18; 56.3%) and in observations (96; 51.3%), followed by co-
financed private universities (7 institutions; 52 observations; 27.8%) and self-
financed private universities (7 institutions; 39 observations; 20.9%).
Table 1
Composition of the panel by CES management type (2017-2026)
CES management
type
N
institutions
% of total
N
observations
Public
18
56.3%
96
Co-financed private
7
21.9%
52
Self-financed private
7
21.9%
39
Total
32
100.0%
187
Source: SCImago Institutions Rankings, 2017-2026 editions, and CES Register,
Ecuador (www.ces.gob.ec
).
Temporal coverage grows over the period: the 2017 and 2018 editions
include only 6 and 8 Ecuadorian universities, respectively, in both cases those with
the longest presence in Scopus. From 2019 onward, the number of HEIs in the SIR
rises steadily until it reaches 30 institutions in the 2026 edition. This growth reflects
the expansion of Ecuadorian scientific output documented by Herrera-Franco et al.
(2021) and Gutiérrez et al. (2023), and it is uneven across management types: public
universities show greater variability in temporal coverage, whereas the largest co-
financed ones have been present continuously since the early editions.
| Diego Sornoza-Parrales |
e9191
Descriptive statistics for Global Rank by management type
Table 2 summarizes the descriptive statistics for Global Rank across the four
SIR dimensions by CES management type over the full 2017-2026 period. On Overall,
the medians are comparable across the three groups (range 6,087-6,984); dispersion
is greatest among self-financed private universities (SD = 1,779), which reflects the
heterogeneity within that segment.
On Research, self-financed private universities show the most favorable
median (5,484), a result probably influenced by the track record of institutions such
as Universidad San Francisco de Quito. On Innovation, by contrast, co-financed
universities have the best median (6,241) and self-financed ones the worst (7,572),
a reversal of the Research pattern that suggests differentiated institutional profiles.
On Societal, differences are minimal, with medians between 4,687 and 5,379.
Table 2
Descriptive statistics for Global Rank by CES management type and SIR dimension
(2017-2026)
Dimension
Management
type
N
Median
Mean
SD
Min.
Max.
Overall
Public
96
6,935
6,878
1,343
3,476
10,283
Overall
P. Co-financed
52
6,984
6,713
1,308
3,821
9,572
Overall
P. Self-
financed
39
6,087
6,804
1,779
3,908
10,026
Research
Public
96
6,621
6,426
1,705
3,476
9,696
Research
P. Co-financed
52
6,804
6,343
1,646
3,821
9,460
Research
P. Self-
financed
39
5,484
5,949
2,006
3,908
9,805
Innovation
Public
96
6,587
6,937
1,709
4,332
10,505
Innovation
P. Co-financed
52
6,241
6,580
1,608
4,814
10,410
Innovation
P. Self-
financed
39
7,572
7,391
1,637
4,334
10,026
Societal
Public
96
4,735
4,820
1,414
2,220
7,711
Societal
P. Co-financed
52
4,687
4,988
1,404
3,188
6,500
Societal
P. Self-
financed
39
5,379
5,045
1,851
3,390
8,906
Note. Global Rank: lower value = better worldwide standing. SD = standard
deviation. P. = Private. Min. and Max. correspond to the Global Rank observed in the
group for each dimension during 2017-2026.
Kruskal-Wallis test: between-group comparison
Table 3 reports the Kruskal-Wallis results. In none of the four SIR dimensions
are there statistically significant differences among the three management types (all
p values ≥ 0.059). The highest H statistic corresponds to Innovation (H = 5.639; p =
0.060), which comes close to the conventional significance threshold without
reaching it. Effect sizes (epsilon²) are very small in all dimensions (range: -0.007 to
| Diego Sornoza-Parrales |
e9191
+0.020), indicating no practically relevant association between management type
and global standing in the SIR. Because no test reached statistical significance,
Dunn's post hoc test with Bonferroni correction was not applicable.
Table 3
Results of the Kruskal-Wallis test for Global Rank by CES management type
SIR
dimension
Total
N
H
(df=2)
p-
value
Sig.
epsilon²
epsilon²
interpretation
Overall
187
0.810
0.667
n.s.
-0.007
No effect
Research
187
2.560
0.278
n.s.
+0.003
Small
Innovation
187
5.639
0.060
n.s.
+0.020
Small
Societal
187
0.797
0.671
n.s.
-0.007
No effect
Note. df = degrees of freedom. n.s. = not significant (p ≥ 0.05). epsilon² = epsilon-
squared (effect size). Interpretation thresholds: epsilon² ≥ 0.06 = moderate effect;
epsilon² ≥ 0.14 = large effect. Dunn's post hoc test (Bonferroni correction) not
applicable because no Kruskal-Wallis result was significant.
Spearman correlation
The Spearman correlation between edition year and Global Rank Overall,
shown in Table 4, points to a consistent and notably robust pattern. All three
management types show high, highly significant positive correlations (rho between
+0.706 and +0.817; p < 0.001 in each), which indicates that the Global Rank of
Ecuadorian universities trends upward over time in public, co-financed private, and
self-financed private universities alike. The correlation is strongest for public
universities (rho = +0.817), followed by co-financed private universities (rho =
+0.787) and, last, self-financed private universities (rho = +0.706). The differences
in correlation size between groups are modest and do not support claims of divergent
trajectories.
Table 4
Spearman correlation between edition year and Global Rank Overall by management
Type
Management
type
N
observations
Spearman's
rho
p-
value
Trend interpretation
Public
96
+0.817
<
0.001
Significant relative
decline (upward trend in
rank)
Co-financed
private
52
+0.787
<
0.001
Significant relative
decline (upward trend in
rank)
Self-financed
private
39
+0.706
<
0.001
Significant relative
decline (upward trend in
rank)
| Diego Sornoza-Parrales |
e9191
Note. Positive rho: Global Rank increases over time (the institution falls in relative
worldwide standing). Analyses were run on individual institution-edition data (N per
group, not annual medians). p < 0.001 in all three cases.
Change in median Global Rank Overall by group (2017-2026)
Table 5 breaks down the temporal evolution of standing by edition year. The
median Global Rank values of the three groups start from similar levels in 2017
(between 4,134 and 4,814) and rise to substantially higher values in 2026 (between
8,140 and 9,160), with no group holding a consistently superior position throughout
the period. In terms of temporal dynamics, self-financed private universities follow
the most irregular trajectory: they have the best median standing in 2017, 2018, and
2020 but the weakest in 2025 and 2026. Co-financed universities show the best
relative median performance in the 2024 and 2025 editions. Public universities follow
the most stable trajectory, with smaller year-to-year fluctuations.
Table 5
Median Global Rank Overall by management type and SIR edition year
SIR year
Public
P. Co-financed
P. Self-financed
Total N
2017
4,590
4,814
4,134
6
2018
4,668
4,994
4,888
8
2019
5,294
5,268
5,197
12
2020
5,883
5,778
4,921
16
2021
6,113
6,401
5,144
21
2022
6,832
7,014
6,087
24
2023
7,711
7,562
7,243
21
2024
7,532
7,078
7,826
22
2025
7,947
7,437
8,130
27
2026
8,526
8,140
9,160
30
Note. Values are medians of the Global Rank Overall of the group's institutions in
each edition. Total N = number of Ecuadorian institutions included in the SIR in each
edition. Lower value = better worldwide standing. P. = Private.
Bibliometric parity across management types: regulatory convergence
The data do not support the hypothesis of significant differences between
management types. This result may seem counterintuitive given the advantage
private universities show in absolute biomedical output (Sisa et al., 2024), but it fits
the regulatory convergence argument: the LOES and the CACES evaluation model
impose requirements for indexed scientific output with equal weight on all types of
HEIs, whatever their source of funding (Sisa et al., 2020; Gutiérrez et al., 2023). This
uniform regulatory pressure would have acted as a leveling mechanism on
institutional research incentives, narrowing preexisting gaps between management
types.
International evidence supports the regulatory convergence argument well.
Fu et al. (2023) showed that in Indonesia the 2014 and 2017 reforms raised output
| Diego Sornoza-Parrales |
e9191
in all types of universities without producing growth differences between groups.
Gutiérrez et al. (2023) observed the same pattern in Ecuador, where every CACES
evaluation cycle coincided with output increases in both public and private
institutions.
From the standpoint of scientific production theory, the result is also
consistent with Lepori et al. (2019), who argue that scientific output scales
fundamentally with institutional resources; this may reflect convergence in the
availability of research resources across the three types of Ecuadorian HEIs. The
divergence from Sisa et al. (2024) is explained by the fact that the present study is
methodologically based on the SIR Global Rank as a relative measure of standing that
incorporates impact and excellence indicators, not just volume, and covers all
disciplines.
Ranking expansion or real slowdown
The second finding, the strong positive correlation between edition year and
Global Rank in all three groups (rho = 0.706-0.817; p < 0.001), has to be interpreted
in light of two phenomena that may or may not overlap: the displacement effect
produced by the growth of the ranking, and a presumed real deterioration in the
relative position of Ecuadorian universities.
On the first point, as explained earlier, the expansion of the SIR is easy to
document: the total number of institutions included has risen from roughly 3,300 in
2017 to more than 11,000 in 2026, an increase of over 230% in ten years (Carta et
al., 2021; SCImago, 2026). This structural growth pushes every institution's Global
Rank to a higher number even when its absolute output has increased, held steady,
or fallen.
The expansion effect alone, however, does not account for the whole
phenomenon. Rodríguez et al. (2022) found signs of a slowdown in Ecuador's
scientific output beginning in 2017, compared with the momentum of the previous
decade. Gutiérrez et al. (2023) also noted that 2019 to 2021 were especially affected
by the slowing of the CACES evaluation cycles and by the impact of the COVID-19
pandemic. The Prometeo Program, which had acted as a catalyst for high-impact
output between 2011 and 2015, was gradually wound down between 2016 and 2018,
removing a powerful stimulus (Sisa et al., 2020).
Both factors together produce the observed positive correlation. Separating
the two effects precisely would require comparing the Global Rank trajectory of
Ecuadorian HEIs against a baseline simulating the purely structural displacement
expected from the growth in the total number of institutions. Such an analysis lies
beyond the scope of this study but represents a relevant line for future research.
From a university management perspective, the relative decline shared by all three
groups indicates that the gap in global standing is a systemic challenge for the
Ecuadorian university system as a whole, not a problem specific to one management
type.
Conclusions
| Diego Sornoza-Parrales |
e9191
This study examines the association between institutional management type
and the bibliometric performance of Ecuadorian universities in the SCImago
Institutions Rankings during 2017-2026, using an unbalanced longitudinal panel of
187 observations for 32 HEIs classified into three types under CES regulations.
First, there are no statistically significant differences among Ecuadorian
public, co-financed private, and self-financed private universities in any of the four
SIR Global Rank dimensions evaluated (Overall, Research, Innovation, Societal); the
H statistics fall short of the conventional significance threshold in every case, and
effect sizes are very small (epsilon² ≤ 0.020). This parity is consistent with the
regulatory convergence argument. Evaluation under the CACES system would have
equalized institutional research incentives across management types, leaving
funding type with little predictive weight for relative bibliometric standing.
Second, all three management types show a solid relative decline in
worldwide standing, and a homogeneous one across groups (rho from +0.706 to
+0.817; p < 0.001). This homogeneity is linked to the combination of two things: the
structural displacement caused by the expansion of the universe of institutions in
the SIR, and the relative slowdown of Ecuadorian scientific output after the
Prometeo Program ended and the CACES evaluation cycles slowed. As shown above,
the decline is not specific to any management type, which reinforces its
interpretation as a systemic phenomenon.
Third, the implications for university policy are that interventions seeking to
improve the bibliometric standing of Ecuadorian HEIs in global rankings should
operate at the system level rather than be segmented by management type. The
priorities would be: (a) achieving a sustained increase in the number of highly
productive researchers across all HEIs; (b) strengthening active international
collaboration, especially coauthorship with authors at institutions ranked higher in
the SIR; and (c) reinstating talent-attraction programs equivalent to Prometeo, with
medium- and long-term evaluation of bibliometric impact.
The study has several limitations: the unbalanced panel over-represents the
most recent editions and the most productive HEIs; country quartile data are
available only for the 2026 edition; and disaggregated financial data are lacking for
each HEI. These limitations can be read as agendas for future research.
References
Carta, M. G., Angermeyer, M. C., & Tagliagambe, S. (2021). The trend of scientific
productivity of Chinese, European Union, and United States universities and
private companies: ¿Does the future belong to E-technology companies?
Publications, 9(2), 18. https://doi.org/10.3390/publications9020018
De la Flor-Martínez, M., Galindo-Moreno, P., & Sánchez-Fernández, E. (2017).
Evaluation of scientific output in Dentistry in Spanish universities. Medicina
Oral Patología Oral y Cirugía Bucal, 22(1), e1-e8.
https://doi.org/10.4317/medoral.21656
de la Poza, E., Merello, P., & Barberá, A. (2021). Universities' reporting on SDGs:
| Diego Sornoza-Parrales |
e9191
Using THE Impact Rankings to model and measure their contribution to
sustainability. Sustainability
, 13(4), 2038.
https://doi.org/10.3390/su13042038
Feyen, J. (2021). Pros and cons of university ranking. Maskana, 12(1), 1-4.
https://doi.org/10.18537/mskn.12.01.00
Fu, Y. C., Macasaet, B. T., & Salvador-Quetzal, A. (2023). In pursuit of excellence:
A historical investigation of scientific production in Indonesia's higher
education system, 1990-2020. Higher Education, 88(2), 523-549.
https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-023-01128-3
Gálvez-Contreras, A. Y., Guzmán-Muñiz, J., & Moy-López, N. A. (2022). Contributions
of Latin America to scientific research in neuroscience and psychology.
Revista Mexicana de Neurociencia, 23(2).
https://doi.org/10.24875/rmn.21000034
Gerón-Piñón, G., Solana-González, P., & Trigueros-Preciado, S. (2021). Management
indicators: Their impact on Latin-American universities' accreditation.
Quality in Higher Education, 27(2), 184-205.
https://doi.org/10.1080/13538322.2021.1890318
Gutiérrez, G., Yaguarema, M., & Ayala, M. (2023). Impact of government evaluation
and accreditation processes on the research output of universities in
developing countries: An X-ray of the young Ecuadorian academia. Frontiers
in Education, 8
, Article 1093083.
https://doi.org/10.3389/feduc.2023.1093083
Herrera-Franco, G., Montalván-Burbano, N., & Mora-Frank, C. (2021). Scientific
research in Ecuador: A bibliometric analysis. Publications, 9(4), 55.
https://doi.org/10.3390/publications9040055
Javed, Y., Ahmad, S., & Khahro, S. H. (2020). Evaluating the research performance
of Islamabad-based higher education institutes. SAGE Open, 10(1).
https://doi.org/10.1177/2158244020902085
Lepori, B., Geuna, A., & Mira, A. (2019). Scientific output scales with resources: A
comparison of US and European universities. PLOS ONE, 14(10), e0223415.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0223415
Mayta-Tovalino, F., Pacheco-Mendoza, J., & Díaz-Soriano, A. M. (2021). Bibliometric
study of the national scientific production of all Peruvian schools of dentistry
in Scopus. International Journal of Dentistry, 2021, 5510209.
https://doi.org/10.1155/2021/5510209
Millones Gómez, P. A., Yangali Vicente, J. S., & Arispe Alburqueque, C. M. (2021).
Research policies and scientific production: A study of 94 Peruvian
universities. PLOS ONE, 16(5), e0252410.
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0252410
Moreno-Gómez, J., Calleja-Blanco, J., & Moreno-Gómez, G. (2019). Measuring the
efficiency of the Colombian higher education system: A two-stage approach.
International Journal of Educational Management, 34(4), 794-804.
https://doi.org/10.1108/ijem-07-2019-0236
Nassa, A. K., & Arora, J. (2021). Revisiting ranking of academic institutions. DESIDOC
Journal of Library & Information Technology, 41(1), 5-19.
https://doi.org/10.14429/djlit.41.1.16673
Nguyen, N. D., Nguyen, T. D., & Dao, K. T. (2021). Effects of institutional policies
and characteristics on research productivity at Vietnam science and
| Diego Sornoza-Parrales |
e9191
technology universities. Heliyon, 7(1), e06024.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2021.e06024
Pérez Anzardo, L. E., González Ortega, R., & Bruzón Sosa, P. (2022). TI in the
institutional scientific productivity of Ecuador, Cuba and Colombia. SIASAT,
7(1), 28-39. https://doi.org/10.33258/siasat.v7i1.109
Quintero-Quintero, W., Blanco-Ariza, A. B., & Garzón-Castrillon, M. A. (2022).
Investigation related to intellectual capital and scientific production in
Colombia public universities: A review from Scopus. Education Research
International, 2022, 9039109. https://doi.org/10.1155/2022/9039109
Robinson-García, N., Torres-Salinas, D., & Herrera-Viedma, E. (2019). Mining
university rankings: Publication output and citation impact as their basis.
Research Evaluation, 28(3), 232-240.
https://doi.org/10.1093/reseval/rvz014
Rodríguez, V., Flores-Sanchez, M., & Zambrano, C. H. (2022). Analysis of Ecuador's
SCOPUS scientific production during the 2001-2020 period by means of
standardized citation indicators. Heliyon, 8(4), e09329.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2022.e09329
Santos, J. M. R. C. A. (2022). On the role and assessment of research at European
Universities of Applied Sciences. Journal of Higher Education Theory and
Practice, 22(14). https://doi.org/10.33423/jhetp.v22i14.5537
SCImago Research Group. (2026). SCImago Institutions Rankings: Methodology.
https://www.scimagoir.com/methodology.php
Sisa, I., Abad-Sojos, A., & Espinosa, I. (2020). A decade of Ecuador's efforts to raise
its health research output: A bibliometric analysis. Global Health Action,
14(1), 1855694. https://doi.org/10.1080/16549716.2020.1855694
Sisa, I., Caicedo-Potosí, J., & Cordovez, M. (2024). One hundred years of Ecuadorian
biomedical scientific output and its association with the main causes of
mortality: A bibliometric study. Frontiers in Medicine, 11, Article 1395433.
https://doi.org/10.3389/fmed.2024.1395433
Szluka, P., Csajbók, E., & Győrffy, B. (2023). Relationship between bibliometric
indicators and university ranking positions. Scientific Reports, 13(1), 14193.
https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-023-35306-1
Taylor, R. C., Liang, X., & Laubichler, M. D. (2021). Systematic shifts in scaling
behavior based on organizational strategy in universities. PLOS ONE, 16(10),
e0254582. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0254582
Vargas-Cuentas, N. I., & Roman-Gonzalez, A. (2021). Analysis of the Bolivian
universities scientific production. Advances in Science Technology and
Engineering Systems Journal, 6(1), 1222-1228.
https://doi.org/10.25046/aj0601139
| Diego Sornoza-Parrales |
Estrategia y Gestión Universitaria EGU
About the main author
Diego Sornoza
-Parrales: h
e holds a PhD in Education from Western University
(Canada) and a Master’s degree in Information Technology Management from
Tecnológico de Monterrey (Mexico). He is an Associate Professor and researcher at
the State University of the South of Manabí (UNESUM). An accredited researcher with
SENESCYT, he has authored over 30 indexed publications in the fields of artificial
intelligence in education, bibliometrics, quality assurance in higher education, and
civil engineering.
Declaration of author responsibility
Elina Pulido Acanda
1:
Conceptualization, Data curation, Formal analysis,
Investigation, Methodology, Resources, Software, Supervision,
Financing:
Own resources
Special Acknowledgments: